One of Michael’s pet peeves with me is that I’ll perfect a recipe, and then move on to the next challenge. He claims that once a recipe is perfected, it’s never to be seen again.
I say that’s nonsense.
He’s completely mistaken.
Ok, yeah. He might be right..
This past summer, I wanted to recreate Mike’s favorite peanut butter pie that I buy for him from the patisserie at my beloved Wegmans. I thought that the whipped peanut butter filling would be my challenge, but it turned out that the crust was the challenge! I tried several different crusts (oreo, graham cracker, etc) before I actually got it right. Because this pie is for him, it was only right that Mike should be the taste tester, and as the pie recipe progressed, he was actually the one who chose the final crust. “You nailed it, mom”…was finally music to my ears!!
I admit, I haven’t made it in a while, and he’s been asking for it on a weekly basis, probably for the last three months. I figured I better get it made before I prove him right!
I think the best part of this dessert is that you can make it into the actual pie, or make it into a tartlet, a cake, mini dessert cups, or bake it right in individual canning jars for easy transport! Mike doesn’t care what shape or form it is when I make it, as long as I actually make it!! He was just as happy with them in jars this time around, as he was with the tart shown above. He didn’t even mention the missing Reeses cups!
Life is good. Life is “whipped peanut butter and a happy son” good.
Peanut Butter Pie Jars
You can easily make this into a 9” x 13” pan by doubling the recipe for the crust, the whipped peanut butter, and the whipped cream.
Brownie Crust
3/4 cup all purpose flour
½ cup unsweetened cocoa
½ tsp baking powder
¼ tsp salt
½ cup butter, melted
1 cup sugar
2 eggs
1 tsp vanilla
Heat oven to 350 degrees. Prepare pan(s) or jars by spraying with nonstick cooking spray.
In a large bowl, combine the flour, cocoa, baking powder, salt, butter, sugar, eggs, and vanilla. Mix until well blended. Pour into prepared pan(s) or jars. Bake for about 30 minutes or until toothpick, when inserted, comes out clean. Let cool completely.
Whipped Peanut Butter
1 – 8 oz package cream cheese
1 cup peanut butter
1 ½ cups heavy cream
½ cup powdered sugar
1 tsp vanilla
In mixing bowl, whip the heavy cream and powdered sugar until stiff peaks form. Transfer to another bowl, and set aside. In mixing bowl, cream together the cream cheese , peanut butter, and vanilla. Fold in the whipped cream until it’s well blended.
Spread over brownie crust.
Whipped Cream:
1 ½ cups heavy cream
1 tsp sugar (or more, depending on how sweet you like your cream)
1 tsp vanilla
In a large mixing bowl, whip the heavy cream and sugar until stiff peaks form. Stir in the vanilla. Refrigerate until ready to use. Spread over whipped peanut butter.
Chocolate Sauce:
Note: Don’t make this until you have assembled the pie, and are ready to drizzle with chocolate sauce.
½ cup semi-sweet chocolate chips
1-2 tbsp heavy cream
In a small microwave proof bowl, add the chips and one tablespoon of heavy cream. Cook on high in your microwave for 30 seconds. Remove from microwave, and stir until all of the chips are melted. If it’s too thick to drizzle, add another tablespoon of heavy cream, and keep adding drops of heavy cream until it’s “drizzle” consistency.
Drizzle over whipped cream.
Assemble the Pie:
Brownie Crust
Whipped Peanut Butter
Whipped Cream
Chocolate Sauce
Mini Reeses Cups (Optional)
It doesn’t matter whether you’re making a pie, mini tartlets, a big tartlet, a cake, or individual jars, the crust is the first layer. You can keep it right in the pan that it was baked, unless you’re using a removable bottom tart pan.
Spread the whipped peanut butter over the crust. Top with whipped cream. Drizzle with the chocolate sauce. Garnish with a mini Reeses cup.
Enjoy!
Oh, those look amazing! I will definitely have to try this recipe, thanks so much for sharing…. 🙂
Thank you so much Sheryl!! I’m so glad you stopped by! Let me know how you like them if you do make them!! 🙂
These look and sound sensational! I love them in the jars! I would really love to try one. I must make them soon x Thanks for sharing Prudy x
Recipes are made for sharing, Dimple!! Except for those people who think they’re going to take them with them (you know..when they pass into the great beyond… kick the bucket…) xx
So true! And so sad that some people think like that. I get so so happy sharing! That’s what life is about and learning from one another too! in this short yet precious time xx
What a great idea–pie in a jar! This just gave me a great idea for my next dinner party or baby shower! I, too, make recipes like these about once a year. More out of fear of overindulging than of conquering the recipe and moving on. 🙂
Awesome Ngan… please share your idea when you do it!! I can’t wait to see! 🙂
Love the brownie crust and I am a sucker for dessert in a jar. Fluffy, creamy peanut butter oh this is decadent, love it!!
Thank you Suzanne! I love desserts in jars too…I’ve been seeing a lot of cupcakes in jars lately.. I’m thinking I LOVE that!!
These are so cute! I loooooove peanut butter and chocolate together, and could EASILY put away one of these by myself. Great recipe Prudy 🙂
Thank you Jess! They don’t last long in my house! And me too.. Peanut butter and chocolate were made for each other! xx
Never seen a pie in a jar before, what a great party idea! I’m not a huge peanut butter fan- any other filling suggestions??
I would just leave the peanut butter out, double, or triple the recipe with the cream cheese and whipped cream.. Maybe add some fresh raspberries or strawberries. Or if you can get chocolate sandwich cookies such as Oreos, maybe break them up and add to the cream cheese mixture. Or mini chocolate chips! Or toffee bits! 🙂
Ohhhhh yum. Gotta try it!!
WOW! Love in a jar! I’m making these asap. Brilliant Prudy. I’ll let you know how I fare (and how many pounds I’ve gained!) 😉
Lol.. let me know how you like them! 🙂
I think its the curse of a foodies husband. Mine says the same thing, that or, why can’t you leave a recipe alone. I’ll make a something, he’ll love it, and then I continue to improve it. These look awesome, and I’m sure my husband will be begging me to make them all the time
I think you’re right!! I get the rolling of the eyes every time I say I’m trying a new recipe. Everyone in the house would be just as happy if I made macaroni and cheese, and burgers all the time!
Oh my….where to begin….first, I love individual desserts, like my very own special treat that I do not have to share!! Then I love chocolate, then I love layers of flavors, whipped cream, whipped peanut butter – lots of soft, luxurious textures in my mouth! And I love the assortment of glass jars you used! Your husband’s a very lucky man!!
Thank you!! Lol.. I made them in different jars for the different sized eaters in the house… I was worried that they wouldn’t look good!
These look so cute and decadent! And the different jars add a great shabby chic element!
Thank you!! Lol, I’m glad you said that. Shabby chic is good.. Really good!! I was worried that it would look more like dime store… Reality is that I made different sizes for the different sized eaters in my house.. The smallest for my daughter who eats like a bird!
Chocolate AND peanut butter – wow, these look amazing 🙂
Thank you! I’m pleased with this recipe.. The peanut butter part is the best.. 🙂
Lol, I’m the same way – I never made a recipe twice, even though my husband and friends/family members love it. I blame the blog – I’m always trying new things so I can post about it. These peanut butter pie jars are incredible! Michael is a lucky man for you to perfect this recipe. Each layer is absolute perfection and together? Magic. I love that you made them in adorable single serving jars (although knowing me, I’d eat three jars in a row!).
Lol.. I think you just hit the nail on the head.. it’s always about getting that next new recipe to post on the blog!! I always want to make sure that the recipe is spot on before I post it, so sometimes it takes a few tries before I’m even willing to post! The single jars work out so well, because my kids have different appetites! It works out better that way, so I don’t have half eaten desserts all over the fridge!! Thanks so much for stopping by…I’m so glad you did! 🙂
Let me know!! 🙂
I must say this is a lot of work but the end product is worth all the trouble taken. I wish I could eat this for my dessert. I’ve just had my dinner. There is no dessert today!
You’d be surprised at just how easy they are! 🙂 I was actually feeling guilty when I was making them, thinking that I really could have made them so much sooner for Mike. They’re not that hard to make at all.. 🙂
Yum–that looks so good, and cute in those little jars! 🙂
Thank you Nancy! 🙂 I was just drooling over your cheesy cauliflower.. What a great recipe!
These look so fabulous! You may have just negated that salad I had for lunch (:
The salad just paved the way for the peanut butter!! Thanks so much for stopping by, I’m so happy you did! 🙂
There we go, that sounds so much better! And anytime, I’m happy I found your site! Everything looks delicious
The jars are so cute, would love to try these, whipped peanut butter sounds sensational. 😀
There is definitely something about whipped peanut butter. To be honest, that’s my most favorite part of this dessert! 🙂
These look so adorable! So are there any dishes you make that Michael sais are nog quite perfect? I would suspect they are and he is just hoping you will keep making them 😉
Michael is my fussy child, so there are plenty of things I prepare that he won’t even give a second glance, let alone try them!! 🙂
These look and sound absolutely amazing!
Thanks so much Jessica!! Give them a try…I think you’ll like them! Thanks so much for stopping by, I’m so happy you did! 🙂
Yum! These look incredible. I had the most amazing peanut pie in a restaurant recently and have been dreaming of it ever since! Defo need to give yours a go! Loving peanut butter at the mo, it’s snuck up on me and now I’m addicted!!
Isn’t that funny how we go through phases of food addictions?!! Peanut butter is definitely a good one to be addicted to… I love it too. Thank you Claire! xx 🙂
WOW! I wish I could have a big spoon full right now! YUM!
It’s the peanut butter that pulls us all in… 🙂 Thanks so much for stopping by…I’m so happy you did.. 🙂
Ok seriously, that whipped peanut butter?! Can you please send me a gallon of it?? Holy cow do these look good.
Pingback: #100happydays: chocolate peanut butter brownie molten pots | love in the kitchen ♥